Competitive Analysis of IntactProtein Lysis Buffer Versus Competitors’ Products

NTRODUCTION

Selecting an appropriate lysis buffer is a critical step in Western blotting workflows, as it significantly influences the efficiency of protein extraction, the preservation of protein integrity, and the retention of post-translational modifications. The choice of buffer composition—including detergents, salts, and protease/phosphatase inhibitors—directly affects the solubilization of target proteins, especially those that are membrane-bound or present in low abundance (Ghosh et al., 2014; Mahmood & Yang, 2012). An inadequate lysis buffer may result in poor protein yield, degradation, or loss of critical epitopes, ultimately compromising detection sensitivity and reproducibility (Gao & Xu, 2015). Therefore, optimizing lysis conditions tailored to the cell type and target proteins is essential for generating reliable and interpretable Western blot data (Rao & Møller, 2011).

MATERIALS

IntactProteinTM Cell-Tissue Lysis Kit (Cat#415, Genuin Biotechnologies). RIPA Lysis and Extraction Buffer (Supplier A).RIPA Buffer (Supplier B).RIPA Lysis Buffer (Supplier C).

Protease and Phosphatase Inhibitor Cocktail (Supplier C). This cocktail was individually added to the buffers from Suppliers A, B, and C during use.

METHODS & RESULTS

Experiment 1

Methods. To evaluate and compare the total protein extraction efficiency of the IntactProteinTM Cell-Tissue Lysis Kit (#415) with that of competing products, we used HepG2 and HeLa cells as representative models and measured the protein yield using the BCA assay.

Results

Table 1: Total protein yield obtained using lysis buffers from different vendors.

Figure 1: Total protein yield obtained using lysis buffers from different vendors.Conclusion: Compared to similar products from other vendors, the IntactProteinTM Cell-Tissue

Lysis Kit (#415) yields a higher total protein extraction from cell samples.

Experiment 2

Methods. To assess and compare both the total protein extraction efficiency and the preservation of protein post-translational modifications (PTMs) offered by the IntactProteinTM Cell-Tissue Lysis Kit (#415) versus competing products, we used HepG2 and HeLa cells as representative models. Western blot analysis was conducted using antibodies targeting proteins of varying molecular weights as well as proteins with specific phosphorylation and methylation modifications. The following KD-validated rabbit monoclonal antibodies from Genuin Biotechnologies were used: anti-Huntingtin (HTT) (Cat#62159), anti-ATP6V1A (Cat#63693), anti-EIF5A (Cat#61574), and anti-phospho-NAK/TBK1 (S172) (Cat#61294). Additionally, a rabbit monoclonal antibody against histone H3 mono-methylated at lysine 79 (Cat#1780) was included to assess methylation status. Detection was performed using an HRP-conjugated goat anti-rabbit secondary antibody (Genuin Biotechnologies, Cat#201), and signal development was carried out with the FeQTM ECL Substrate Kit (Genuin Biotechnologies, Cat#226).

Results

Figure 2: Western blot analysis of cell lysates prepared using lysis buffers from different vendors. Conclusion: The conclusions are summarized in Table 2.

Table 2: Western blot comparison results for proteins extracted using lysis buffers from different vendors.

Protein Type	IntactProteinTMCell-Tissue Lysis Kit (Cat#415) Performance	Competitors' Performance
Small/Medium-sized Proteins	Comparable extraction efficiency; clear, single target bands; no non-specific background	Similar extraction efficiency; clear target bands; no significant background
High Molecular Weight Proteins	Clear, sharp target bands; stronger signal intensity; clean background	Increased non-specific background; reduced clarity
Phosphorylated Proteins	Stronger signal intensity; cleaner background	Weaker signals; more background noise
Methylated Proteins	Successfully extracts and detects target signals	Failed to enrich or detect significant methylated protein signals

Experiment 3

Methods. To evaluate and compare the total protein extraction efficiency from tissues using the IntactProteinTM Cell-Tissue Lysis Kit (#415) versus competing products, we employed mouse liver, white adipose tissue, and skeletal muscle as representative samples and measured protein yield with the BCA assay.

Results

Table 3: Total protein yield from tissues obtained using lysis buffers from different vendors.

Conclusion: Compared to similar products from other vendors, the IntactProteinTM Cell-Tissue Lysis Kit (#415) delivers higher total protein yields from mouse adipose tissue and skeletal muscle, while showing comparable yield in mouse liver.

Experiment 4

Methods. To assess and compare both the total protein extraction efficiency and the preservation of protein post-translational modifications (PTMs) offered by the IntactProteinTM Cell-Tissue Lysis Kit (#415) versus competing products, we used mouse liver, white adipose tissue, and skeletal muscle as representative tissues. Western blot analysis was conducted using antibodies targeting proteins of varying molecular weights as well as proteins with specific phosphorylation and methylation modifications. The following KD-validated rabbit monoclonal antibodies from Genuin Biotechnologies were used: anti-Huntingtin (HTT) (Cat#62159), anti-ATP6V1A (Cat#63693), anti-EIF5A (Cat#61574), and anti-phospho-NAK/TBK1 (S172) (Cat#61294). Additionally, a rabbit monoclonal antibody against histone H3 mono-methylated at lysine 79 (Cat#1780) was included to assess methylation status. Detection was performed using an HRP-conjugated goat anti-rabbit secondary antibody (Genuin Biotechnologies, Cat#201), and signal development was carried out with the FeQTM ECL Substrate Kit (Genuin Biotechnologies, Cat#226).

Results

Figure 3: Western blot analysis of tissue lysates prepared using lysis buffers from different vendors.

Conclusion: The conclusions are summarized in Table 4.

Table 4: Western blot comparison results for proteins extracted using lysis buffers from different vendors.

Protein Type / Test	IntactProteinTM Cell-Tissue Lysis Kit (Cat#415) Performance	Competitors' Performance
Small/Medium-sized Proteins (Liver)	Comparable to competitors; both performed well with clear target bands	Comparable; both showed good extraction and band clarity
Small Molecular Weigh Proteins (Adipose & Muscle)	Significantly better extraction; stronger Western blot band signals	Weaker band signals; lower extraction efficiency
High Molecular Weight Proteins	Single, sharp target bands; no abnormal bands; clean background	Abnormal bands above target (indicating gel migration lag); high background noise
Phosphorylated Proteins	Clear, sharp target bands with clean background; strong signal even in muscle samples	High diffuse background; reduced target band intensity, especially in muscle samples
Methylated Proteins	Consistent detection of target methylation bands at expected molecular weight	Failed to effectively detect target methylation signals

GENERAL CONCLUSION & DISCUSSION

The IntactProteinTM Cell-Tissue Lysis Kit (Cat#415) outperformed comparable products from leading global vendors across nearly all evaluated categories. Its unique formulation offers exceptional efficiency in extracting high molecular weight proteins while effectively minimizing protein PTM loss during extraction. Tissue protein extraction and subsequent Western blotting are well-known challenges in molecular biology; in this context, the superior performance of this product in tissue samples establishes it as one of the best-in-class solutions.

REFERENCES

Ghosh, R., Gilda, J. E., & Gomes, A. V. (2014). The necessity of and strategies for improving confidence in the accuracy of western blots. Expert Review of Proteomics, 11(5), 549–560. Mahmood, T., & Yang, P. C. (2012). Western blot: technique, theory, and trouble shooting. North American Journal of Medical Sciences, 4(9), 429–434.

Gao, X., & Xu, X. (2015). Protein extraction methods for proteomic analysis. Proteomics, 15(18), 3131–3141.Rao, R. S., & Møller, I. M. (2011). Pattern of protein extraction from plant tissues for western blot analysis. Plant Science, 180(4), 596–602.

Publications citing our product (Cat#415 )

YaoY,RenZ,YangR, MeiY,DaiY,ChengQ,XuC,XuX,WangS, Kim KM,Noh JH, Zhu J, Zhao N, Liu YU, Mao G, Sima J. Salidroside reduces neuropathology in Alzheimer's disease models by targeting NRF2/SIRT3 pathway. Cell Biosci.2022 Nov 4;12( 1):180. doi:10.1186/s13578-022-00918-z. PMID: 36333711; PMCID: PMC9636768.

He Y, Zhang R, Yu L, Zahr T, Li X, Kim TW, Qiang L. PPARγ Acetylation in Adipocytes Exacerbates BAT Whitening and Worsens Age-Associated Metabolic Dysfunction. Cells. 2023 May 18;12(10):1424. doi: 10.3390/cells12101424. PMID: 37408258; PMCID: PMC10217233.

Kirkpatrick LT, Daughtry MR, El-Kadi S, Shi TH, Gerrard DE. O-GlcNAcylation is a gatekeeper of porcine myogenesis. J Anim Sci. 2022 Nov 1;100(11):skac326. doi: 10.1093/jas/skac326. PMID: 36219104; PMCID: PMC9683508.

Wang Q, Zhang B, Stutz B, Liu ZW, Horvath TL, Yang X. Ventromedial hypothalamic OGT drives adipose tissue lipolysis and curbs obesity. Sci Adv. 2022 Sep 2;8(35):eabn8092. doi: 10.1126/sciadv.abn8092. Epub 2022 Aug 31. PMID: 36044565; PMCID: PMC9432828.

He Y, B'nai Taub A, Yu L, Yao Y, Zhang R, Zahr T, Aaron N, LeSauter J, Fan L, Liu L, Tazebay R, Que J, Pajvani U, Wang L, Silver R, Qiang L. PPARγ Acetylation Orchestrates Adipose Plasticity and Metabolic Rhythms. Adv Sci (Weinh). 2023 Jan;10(2):e2204190. doi: 10.1002/advs.202204190. Epub 2022 Nov 17. PMID: 36394167; PMCID: PMC9839851.

Lu B, Chen S, Guan X, Chen X, Du Y, Yuan J, Wang J, Wu Q, Zhou L, Huang X, Zhao Y. Lactate accumulation induces H4K12la to activate super-enhancer-driven RAD23A expression and promote niraparib resistance in ovarian cancer. Mol Cancer. 2025 Mar 19;24(1):83. doi: 10.1186/s12943-025-02295-w. PMID: 40102876; PMCID: PMC11921584.

Xu C, Mei Y, Yang R, Luo Q, Zhang J, Kou X, Hu J, Wang Y, Li Y, Chen R, Zhang Z, Yao Y, Sima J. Edaravone Dexborneol mitigates pathology in animal and cell culture models of Alzheimer's disease by inhibiting neuroinflammation and neuronal necroptosis. Cell Biosci. 2024 Apr 27;14(1):55. doi: 10.1186/s13578-024-01230-8. PMID: 38678262; PMCID: PMC11056062.

Rimmer LA, Geisbrecht ER, Chao MD, O'Quinn TG, Woodworth JC, Zumbaugh MD.

Skeletal Muscle Metabolism Is Dynamic during Porcine Postnatal Growth. Metabolites. 2024 Jun 26;14(7):357. doi: 10.3390/metabo14070357. PMID: 39057680; PMCID: PMC11279009.

Yu L, Wan Q, Liu Q, Fan Y, Zhou Q, Skowronski AA, Wang S, Shao Z, Liao CY, Ding L, Kennedy BK, Zha S, Que J, LeDuc CA, Sun L, Wang L, Qiang L. IgG is an aging factor that drives adipose tissue fibrosis and metabolic decline. Cell Metab. 2024 Apr 2;36(4):793-807.e5. doi: 10.1016/j.cmet.2024.01.015. Epub 2024 Feb 19. PMID: 38378001; PMCID: PMC11070064.

Zahr T, Boda VK, Ge J, Yu L, Wu Z, Que J, Li W, Qiang L. Small molecule conjugates with selective estrogen receptor β agonism promote anti-aging benefits in metabolism and skin recovery. Acta Pharm Sin B. 2024 May;14(5):2137-2152. doi: 10.1016/j.apsb.2024.01.014. Epub 2024 Jan 29. PMID: 38799642; PMCID: PMC11119546.